When Is An Arch Not An Arch?

by Don Friedman on November 15, 2017

That’s the F/G subway, paralleling 9th Street in Brooklyn, where the tracks cross over Fourth Avenue. The train is elevated here because it crosses over the Gowanus Canal a little to the west at the Smith/9th Street station. As the tracks head east, to the left, they stay at roughly the same elevation as the ground rises (the slope of Park Slope) and so head back underground.

There’s some fine art-decoish brickwork at the station, but what grabs my attention is the structure that carried the load of the trains across the 100-foot width of Fourth Avenue. That big green arch is steel, one of I believe four parallel arches at this spot, and serves as a bridge. There’s another, older subway line under Fourth Avenue (the R/N/D), so a vertical section through this spot is quite complicated.

The thing is, that’s not really an arch. It’s an “arch.” An arch carries vertical load through compression, and has both vertical (gravity) and horizontal (thrust) reactions at its base. This is a structural element that used to be called a “one-bay bent”: two columns that are moment-connected to the beam that connects them. The tip-off is the corner, visible (where the arch bends down on the right into the brick of the station entrance) as a widening of the arched member. That widened corner is the moment connection.

Here’s where classification starts to break down. The arch foundations are buried in the ground, so in theory they could be designed for the horizontal thrust. The thrust would be pushing away from the old buried train tunnel, so it wouldn’t harm it. So if we allow for thrust, the arch could be working as an arch. In other words, once we allow for thrust, arching action exists. The proper shape for a uniformly-loaded arch to remain solely in compression is an inverted catenary curve, but the loading here isn’t uniform. A train can be in the station and uniformly loading the arch, it can be approaching from the Manhattan end of the line and loading the west half of the arch, or it can be approaching from the Brooklyn end of the line and loading the east half of the arch. Arches that have to carry radically different loading cases either have to be very thick to allow for the different compression paths through their material or they have to be able to carry local bending. Similarly, if an arch has a less-than-ideal curve to it, it either needs to be thick or it needs to carry local bending.

What would an arch that can carry local bending look like? It would be a material that can take tension as well as compression like, say, steel. And in areas of sharp curvature it would be wider because of the concentration of bending caused by the geometry. In other words, it would look a lot like the arch above.

The division between arches and one-bay bents is based (1) whether the material is capable of carrying bending as well as compression and (2) on how we choose to analyze them. In this case, given the heavy loads from the trains, it makes more sense to look at this as a bent, but that’s really a matter of taste.

Different Types of Efficiency

October 19, 2017

I seem to keep coming back to train station roofs as I write. That’s happening partly because I travel by train a good amount so I’m looking at those roofs, and partly because they tend to have exposed structure designed by engineers with little or no separate architectural design, which may not make them beautiful […]

Read the full article →

Detailing For The Forces

October 17, 2017

A big part of structural design is “detailing,” which is drawing the way various pieces of a building  are connected. The bridge above (click to enlarge all of the photos) is in Wrocław and has a shorter span than the average American suspension bridge of any era. I walked over it a number of times […]

Read the full article →

Road Trip: For Show Or For Blow

October 14, 2017

(Ignore the flying porpoises. I have no idea what they are.) That’s the roof of a shopping mall in Ottawa. Are those trusses real structure or just for show? Their form (diagonals sloped for tension, deepest at midspan) and location (paired on either side of the columns) both make sense as real structure. If so, […]

Read the full article →

Flavors of Obsolescence

October 13, 2017

This article in Curbed gets the facts right but also, by accident, emphasizes a point of unclarity that has led to a lot of sensational headlines over the years. There are some 2000 bridges of various types in New York City, most of them small. It sounds horrifying that 76 percent are “functionally obsolete” and […]

Read the full article →

All In The Emphasis

October 2, 2017

I find this article in the New York Times about the recent earthquake in Mexico City to be problematic. To be clear, I claim no special knowledge of the quake itself or of Mexico City, but the building process is the same everywhere. To create a building of any significant size, we need a prospective […]

Read the full article →

Planning For Future Floods

September 30, 2017

The South Ferry subway station after Hurricane Sandy, courtesy of the MTA: Here’s a good article on infrastructure improvement, specifically on repairs to mitigate future disasters: 6 rules for rebuilding infrastructure in an era of ‘unprecedented’ weather events. The third rule, “Design for climate change” jumped out at me as it’s something we see every time we […]

Read the full article →

Not Amenable To Easy Analysis

September 27, 2017

Not our project: While discussing a project recently with our client, it became clear that part of our work was going to require arch analysis of a masonry lintel. (The project is a bit sensitive, so I’m going to be vague about the specifics of the location and owner, which fortunately does not require being […]

Read the full article →

A Rebus From 135 Years Ago

September 26, 2017

The engineering magazine ENR used to be called the Engineering News-Record. It was created in 1917 by the merger of two long-time rivals, the Engineering News and the Engineering Record. The Engineering Record went through a series of names early in its history, as it absorbed some other small magazines and searched for an audience. […]

Read the full article →

Historic New Structural Detail

September 19, 2017

Even though construction is still in progress – note the blue tarps and the chain fall – that is a beautiful sight that very few people will ever see. That is the inside of a newly-constructed onion dome. The old dome and cupola, which formed the steeple of St. Vladimir Ukrainian Catholic Church in Elizabeth, […]

Read the full article →