Cartesian Boxes

by Don Friedman on September 15, 2017

One of the oddities of researching early skyscrapers is trying to account for the occupancies. Why would someone build a high-rise* factory in the 1890s? Why would someone build a high-rise tenement? One of the oddest of the oddities is the way that insurance companies dominate the early skyscraper office buildings. New York Life, Metropolitan Life, and Home Insurance each constructed multiple tall buildings in an era when no one even knew if tall buildings were a fad or a permanent fixture of American cities. Why?

The answer is illuminating of how much has changes in the past 120 years and, incidentally, rather depressing. Insurance companies, by the nature of their business, were the first corporations to need filing cabinets not just for paper but for people. They had to store enormous amounts of paper and also the clerks to handle all the paper. The defining feature of tall buildings – the “typical floor” – is a statement of repetition and that is what the insurance companies needed. The picture above, showing the 1915 Equitable Life Assurance building, gives you the idea. Later on, other white-collar professions followed down the same path, but the insurers got there first. Whether digitization and office use of cloud services spell the end for this type of occupancy is not yet certain but it’s an obvious possibility.

Meanwhile, there is a less depressing version of the same idea: storage for archives and books. Unlike people, paper in storage doesn’t need windows. Actually, paper lasts longer when protected from light, so books could be hidden deep within the recesses of, say the New York Public Library. The following pictures show the NYPL stacks, located under the main reading room at the top rear of the building, in sequence of construction. First, the steel-angle columns, I-beam intermediate floor framing, and the top of the tile-arch floor below the stacks; second, the cast-iron shelf structure above the fill on top of the tile arches; third, the completed shelf system with a cement wearing surface over the floor; fourth, the stacks in use.

This may seem like a triumph of rectangular geometry over all other logic, but it’s an amazingly efficient system for storage and retrieval. And, of course, I much prefer the books version to the people version.

* High rise for its time.

Overdue Recognition

September 9, 2017

The Firth of Forth rail bridge now has a plaque regarding its recent elevation to World Heritage status. To revive an old joke, it’s the first forth bridge.

Read the full article →

The Persistence of Stubborn Buildings

September 8, 2017

One more group of old photos, this time a Brooklyn-centric exhibit at BRIC.┬áIt so happens that one of the buildings pictured, and one of the two featured in the Brownstoner article, is the headquarters of the New York and Long Island Coignet Stone Company. We were part of the team that worked on the recent […]

Read the full article →

The Persistence of Happier Memories

September 7, 2017

Old old and new old on Barclay Street: More comparisons of before-and-after photographs: here. They’re far less depressing than yesterday’s set for the simple reason that the current-day photographs show, mostly, buildings that are in still in use a hundred years or more since they were built. The exception is the last pair of photos: […]

Read the full article →

The Persistence of Memory

September 6, 2017

Imagine what the missing building looked like… Depending on my mood, this set of now-and-then photos is either horrifying or depressing. The Catskills resorts may have been cheesy, but a lot of people spent time at those places, as guests and as employees, and the resorts therefore hang on as a large body of people’s […]

Read the full article →

All Gone But Remembered

September 5, 2017

A good and needed piece at The Conversation on demolished buildings. The amount I know about the buildings mentioned varies; I’m by far the most familiar with the old Waldorf Astoria, even though it was torn down before my mother was born. My research into the structure of early tall buildings led me to that […]

Read the full article →

Labor Day Weekend 3

September 4, 2017

Workers building the SS George Washington Carver, a Liberty Ship constructed in California in 1943.

Read the full article →

Labor Day Weekend 2

September 3, 2017

Workers (with a supervisor) building the marble walls of the New York Public Library, 1906.

Read the full article →

Gypsum Is Not Talc

August 29, 2017

I’ve mentioned gypsum block before: it was the masonry-style predecessor to gypsum board, a manufactured pre-fab substitute for rough-coat plaster and lath. The picture above (click to enlarge it) is from an early 1960s building. That’s a standard gyp-block partition in a mechanical room, serving as a fire-rated divider between two spaces. “Gold Bond” was […]

Read the full article →

Is a Non-Dead Building Ghost a Building Zombie?

August 24, 2017

Another old picture, but this one is not quite a ghost. The curved mansard roof (that is visible as a curved pattern on the side wall) was part of the extent building before its unfortunate extension. The extension added one full story and made the mansard level the same size as the typical floors below, […]

Read the full article →